Commentary: A look at Yahweh and how he got that way
‘Hear, O Israel,” Moses cries out in Deuteronomy, “the Lord our God, the Lord is One.”
Published
David O’Reilly is an Inquirer staff writer
‘Hear, O Israel,” Moses cries out in Deuteronomy, “the Lord our God, the Lord is One.”
Known as the Great Admonition, which traditionally observant Jews wear on their foreheads at prayer, it echoes across time as the foundational statement of monotheism informing Judaism, Christianity, and Islam.
But Yahweh, the thunderous voice in the whirlwind who in Exodus makes a covenant with the Israelites, likely traveled a longer and more crowded path to his singular status as “Creator of Heaven and Earth” than the Hebrew Bible makes plain. Such is the argument of Thomas Romer, professor of Hebrew Bible at the College de France and Lausanne University, who presents his case in The Invention of God, recently issued in English by Harvard University Press
To do that, writes Romer, “we must invert the presentation made by the biblical authors and read it against the grain.” He compares early and later versions of certain biblical passages, teases hidden meanings out of the Hebrew, and presents extrabiblical writings and recent archaeological finds from ancient Egypt, Assyria, Phoenicia, Babylon, and the proto-Jewish kingdoms of Israel and Judah.
Romer builds on the consensus of modern Bible scholars that the deity known as YHWH was likely the storm or war god of nomadic tribes living outside Egypt in the second millennium before the Christian era. There is evidence to suggest his early devotees not only spoke his name, Romer writes, but that it was likely pronounced Yahu or Yaho, not Yahweh. Various texts suggest he came from Seir, Edom, or the Midian in what is now Saudi Arabia. These may have included the marginalized people called the Hapiru, a possible source of the word Hebrew.
While some “minimalist” Bible scholars see no historic truth to the Exodus story of Moses leading 600,000 Hebrews out of Egypt, Romer surmises that one of these ancient tribes might have fought or negotiated its freedom from Egypt and made its way north, taking its YHWH worship along. In what would later become the southern kingdom of Judah, it likely encountered indigenous tribes with their own deities, whose pantheons YHWH joined.
Israel and Judah appear to have worshipped Yahweh for centuries in distinctly different ways. In the populated, prosperous northern kingdom of Israel, YHWH was evidently represented in sanctuaries as a calf or bull, likely alongside statues of the deities of Assyria and Babylon – powerful warrior states before which Israel often trembled.
In poor, hardscrabble Judah, meanwhile, Romer concludes, Yahweh was represented in sanctuaries between the 10th and sixth centuries as a human statue seated on a throne surrounded by, or atop, winged mythical creatures known as cherubim.
Romer’s close reading of Solomon’s creation of the great temple described in 1 Kings leads him to surmise that Solomon actually built a room for Yahweh alongside the sanctuary of another deity, likely the sun god Shamash, who was often depicted as a solar disc. He also notes, as have other scholars, that images of Yahweh were sometimes presented alongside those of the female deity Asherah, whom devotees understood to be his wife or consort.
When the Persian king Cyrus permitted their return two decades later, the elite of Judah deduced that Yahweh had punished both kingdoms for worshipping other gods alongside him. Priests and scribes began writing and redacting a history of the Jewish people that depicted Judah and its line of Davidic kings as (mostly) heroically devoted to Yahweh, while vilifying now-vanished Israel for its polytheism and calf icons.
From this worldview, Romer writes, would flow the familiar Bible stories of Moses and the covenant on Mount Sinai, YHWH’S stern abjuration that “thou shalt have no other gods before me,” and Moses’ great admonition that “the Lord our God, the Lord is One.”
The Invention of God does not address the question of whether God is an ontological reality. But Romer presents a scholarly and provocative account of how a minor tribal deity likely grew to become – or revealed himself to be – Lord of Creation.
Published
The legacy of Colin Kaepernick: Young Black NFL players stay silent or be exiled | Opinion
The NFL’s message is clear: Black athletes who want fame, glory and million dollar contracts should shut up about things like police brutality and social justice and play ball.
Raymond E. Janifer, Sr., For The Inquirer
Erin McCarthy
Need some adorable puppy content in your life right now? Meet Drake the Pup Star, son of @NHLFlyers‘ star Ivan Provorov and his girlfriend Madison Fairhurst. He’s kind of a big deal (read: definitely has more TikTok followers than you). inquirer.com/flyers/ivan-pr…
This Philadelphia Flyer’s adorable golden retriever puppy is the next big social media star
Mothers of gunshot victims grieve in real time on social media | Helen Ubiñas
More mothers are sharing their pain lately, refusing to wait on anyone to unapologetically express their sorrow, to tell their stories of grief with posts that are often part therapy, part deterrent.
Helen Ubiñas | Columnist
Confused by the city’s new COVID-19 restrictions? You’re not alone. | Editorial
“People just have to grow up.” That was Mayor Jim Kenney’s message when he and acting Health Commissioner Cheryl Bettigole announced new COVID-19 mitigation requirements.
Tucker Carlson and the American right are taking the wrong lessons from Hungary | Opinion
From a city planning perspective, Hungary does have lessons for Philly and other American cities—but it’s not to support bigotry.
Inquirer LIVE: Down the Shore with Craig LaBan
Inquirer LIVE: Health Report
Inquirer LIVE: Philly Sports with Kevin Negandhi
Inquirer LIVE: U.S. Women’s Soccer
Inquirer LIVE: Julie K. Brown
Because of the delta variant, Diner en Blanc is going to have to be a no for me | Jenice Armstrong
Even when you’re fully vaccinated, there’s still a possibility of becoming infected with the virus just like those beachgoers in Provincetown, Mass.
Jenice Armstrong | Columnist
30 minutes on Tuesday that proved American politics are not a foregone conclusion | Opinion
Both Cuomo’s resignation and the infrastructure bill are an important reminder that everything is impossible until it isn’t.
Arrest Trump for a coup that came too close | Will Bunch
Plus, how to get upbeat about the latest doom and gloom on climate from the UN.
Will Bunch | Columnist
Andrew Seidman
Support from McConnell et al might only have increased the incentive for GOP #PASEN candidates to attack the infrastructure bill. “That’s not who conservative Republicans are taking their marching orders from. It’s Trump.” @JonathanTamari inquirer.com/news/pa-senate…
Biden’s infrastructure bill gave us a preview of a key clash in Pa.’s 2022 Senate race. Here’s what we learned.
Residential schools were a key tool in America’s long history of Native genocide | Perspective
The recent disturbing news from Canada was a reminder that the United States maintained its own system of 367 Indian boarding schools from 1860 until 1978.
David A. Love, Washington Post
An innovative approach to helping Philly kids process trauma | Opinion
A new model for how to deploy telehealth alongside school-based services to help children navigate trauma is being tested at Girard College and has the potential to help even more local students.
Katherine Gilmore Richardson, For The Inquirer
Gov. Wolf isn’t pulling harmful COVID-19 stunts like Florida’s Ron DeSantis. But he’s also not doing enough. | Editorial
Gov. Tom Wolf is not yet doing all he can for Pennsylvanians.
Reject DaBaby’s bigotry on HIV and celebrate authentic work from Southwest Philly’s Donja R. Love | Opinion
It is important to uplift people who live with HIV and have been on the front lines of making our stories visible — especially in the aftermath of DaBaby’s stigmatizing and homophobic remarks.
Abdul-Aliy Muhammad, For The Inquirer
My restaurant is requiring proof of vaccine, and no, this isn’t an attack on your freedom | Opinion
It’s hard to take seriously definitions of “freedom” that include no concerns for one’s neighbors, community, or personal responsibility.
Francis Cretarola, For The Inquirer
Congressman Dwight Evans says the outrage over gun violence isn’t ‘to the level it should be’ | Jenice Armstrong
Even if declaring a gun violence emergency wouldn’t mean the reallocation of more resources, residents need more reassurance that the city recognizes that it is experiencing a major crisis.
Jenice Armstrong | Columnist
It ain’t over till it’s over
We went every August to the same rowhouse on Bellevue Avenue in Atlantic City. Back then, it was truly a residential city, with stucco and brick rowhouses lining each block.